Anfield | Fri 30 Dec 2011 at 19:45 UK local time
| Liverpool | 3 | - | 1 | Newcastle United |
| 25 | Pepe Reina (c) | |
| 2 | Glen Johnson | |
| 3 | Jose Enrique | |
| 5 | Daniel Agger | |
| 37 | Martin Skrtel | |
| 14 | Jordan Henderson | |
| 19 | Stewart Downing | |
| 20 | Jay Spearing | |
| 26 | Charlie Adam | |
| 9 | Andy Carroll | |
| 39 | Craig Bellamy |
| 32 | Alexander Doni | |
| 23 | Jamie Carragher | |
| 34 | Martin Kelly | |
| 8 | Steven Gerrard | |
| 11 | Maxi Rodriguez | |
| 33 | Jonjo Shelvey | |
| 18 | Dirk Kuyt |
Stewart Downing against Sunderland 13 August, Martin Kelly against Arsenal 20 August, Andy Carroll against Wolves 24 September, Charlie Adam and Dirk Kuyt against Everton 1 October, Martin Skrtel and Luis Suarez (twice) against Norwich 22 October, Stewart Downing against West Brom 29 October, Andy Carroll against Swansea 5 November, Jordan Henderson and Stewart Downing against Fulham 5 December, Maxi Rodriguez and courtesy of Shaun Wright-Phillips against QPR 10 December, Luis Suarez (twice) against Aston Villa 18 December and Andy Carroll against Newcastle 30 December.
- Luis Suarez sits out ban for having showed Fulham supporters the finger on 5 December.