| Added | Player | Date | Result | Opponent | Stadium |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| +12 pen | Dirk Kuyt | 17 Apr 2011 | 1-1 | Arsenal | Emirates Stadium |
| +10 | Rio Ngumoha | 25 Aug 2025 | 3-2 | Newcastle United | St James' Park |
| +9 | Darwin Nunez | 02 Mar 2024 | 1-0 | Nottingham Forest | City Ground |
| +8 | Fabio Carvalho | 31 Aug 2022 | 2-1 | Newcastle United | Anfield |
| +7 | Alexis Mac Allister | 22 Feb 2026 | 1-0 | Nottingham Forest | City Ground |
| +7 | Mohamed Salah | 21 Oct 2023 | 2-0 | Everton | Anfield |
| +7 | Martin Skrtel | 21 Dec 2014 | 2-2 | Arsenal | Anfield |
| +7 | Luis Suarez | 21 Apr 2013 | 2-2 | Chelsea | Anfield |
| +6 | Divock Origi | 02 Dec 2018 | 1-0 | Everton | Anfield |
| +6 | Christian Benteke | 11 May 2016 | 1-1 | Chelsea | Anfield |
| +6 pen | Christian Benteke | 06 Mar 2016 | 2-1 | Crystal Palace | Selhurst Park |
| +6 | Divock Origi | 13 Dec 2015 | 2-2 | West Bromwich Albion | Anfield |
| +6 | Luis Suarez | 22 Mar 2014 | 6-3 | Cardiff City | Cardiff City Stadium |
| +6 | David N'Gog | 25 Oct 2009 | 2-0 | Manchester United | Anfield |
| +5 pen | Mohamed Salah | 14 Sep 2025 | 1-0 | Burnley | Turf Moor |
| +5 | Luis Diaz | 05 Nov 2023 | 1-1 | Luton Town | Kenilworth Road |
| +5 | Alisson Becker | 16 May 2021 | 2-1 | West Bromwich Albion | The Hawthorns |
| +5 pen | James Milner | 05 Oct 2019 | 2-1 | Leicester City | Anfield |
| +5 | Adam Lallana | 23 Jan 2016 | 5-4 | Norwich City | Carrow Road |
| +5 pen | Steven Gerrard | 01 Mar 2014 | 3-0 | Southampton | St Mary's |
| +5 | Steven Gerrard | 06 Dec 2008 | 3-1 | Blackburn Rovers | Ewood Park |
| +4 | Cody Gakpo | 04 Jan 2026 | 2-2 | Fulham | Craven Cottage |
| +4 | Mohamed Salah | 15 Aug 2025 | 4-2 | Bournemouth | Anfield |
| +4 | Dominik Szoboszlai | 06 Dec 2023 | 2-0 | Sheffield United | Bramall Lane |
| +4 | Diogo Jota | 30 Apr 2023 | 4-3 | Tottenham Hotspur | Anfield |
| +4 | Divock Origi | 04 Dec 2021 | 1-0 | Wolves | Molineux |
| +4 | Sadio Mané | 02 Nov 2019 | 2-1 | Aston Villa | Villa Park |
| +4 | Ragnar Klavan | 01 Jan 2018 | 2-1 | Burnley | Turf Moor |
| +4 | Sadio Mané | 19 Dec 2016 | 1-0 | Everton | Goodison Park |
| +4 | Ryan Babel | 25 Apr 2010 | 4-0 | Burnley | Turf Moor |
| +4 | Fernando Torres | 01 Feb 2009 | 2-0 | Chelsea | Anfield |
| +4 | Steven Gerrard | 23 Aug 2008 | 2-1 | Middlesbrough | Anfield |
| +4 | Gary McAllister | 16 Apr 2001 | 3-2 | Everton | Goodison Park |
| +3 | Ibrahima Konaté | 31 Jan 2026 | 4-1 | Newcastle United | Anfield |
| +3 | Darwin Nunez | 18 Jan 2025 | 2-0 | Brentford | Gtech Community Stadium |
| +3 | Darwin Nunez | 21 Jan 2024 | 4-0 | Bournemouth | Dean Court |
| +3 | Darwin Nunez | 27 Aug 2023 | 2-1 | Newcastle United | St James' Park |
| +3 | Virgil Van Dijk | 23 Feb 2022 | 6-0 | Leeds United | Anfield |
| +3 | Mohamed Salah | 19 Jan 2020 | 2-0 | Manchester United | Anfield |
| +3 | Sadio Mané | 10 Mar 2019 | 4-2 | Burnley | Anfield |
| +3 | Sadio Mané | 19 Jan 2019 | 4-3 | Crystal Palace | Anfield |
| +3 | Sadio Mané | 20 Aug 2018 | 2-0 | Crystal Palace | Selhurst Park |
| +3 | Steven Gerrard | 13 Mar 2012 | 3-0 | Everton | Anfield |
| +3 pen | Dirk Kuyt | 20 Jan 2010 | 2-0 | Tottenham Hotspur | Anfield |
| +3 | Fernando Torres | 29 Dec 2009 | 1-0 | Aston Villa | Villa Park |
| +3 | David N'Gog | 19 Aug 2009 | 4-0 | Stoke City | Anfield |
| +3 | Yossi Benayoun | 21 Apr 2009 | 4-4 | Arsenal | Anfield |
| +3 | Álvaro Arbeloa | 08 Nov 2008 | 3-0 | West Bromwich Albion | Anfield |
| +3 | Mark Gonzalez | 09 Dec 2006 | 4-0 | Fulham | Anfield |
| +3 | Igor Biscan | 16 Oct 2004 | 4-2 | Fulham | Craven Cottage |
| +2 | Cody Gakpo | 30 Nov 2025 | 2-0 | West Ham United | London Stadium |
| +2 | Sadio Mané | 12 Sep 2021 | 3-0 | Leeds United | Elland Road |
| +2 | Luis Suarez | 22 Dec 2012 | 4-0 | Fulham | Anfield |
| +2 | Joe Cole | 01 Jan 2011 | 2-1 | Bolton Wanderers | Anfield |
| +2 | Yossi Benayoun | 04 Apr 2009 | 1-0 | Fulham | Craven Cottage |
| +2 | Dirk Kuyt | 05 Oct 2008 | 3-2 | Manchester City | City of Manchester Stadium |
| +2 pen | Dirk Kuyt | 20 Oct 2007 | 2-1 | Everton | Goodison Park |
| +2 | Fernando Torres | 07 Oct 2007 | 2-2 | Tottenham Hotspur | Anfield |
| +2 | Neil Mellor | 28 Nov 2004 | 2-1 | Arsenal | Anfield |
| +2 | Sami Hyypia | 20 Mar 2004 | 1-0 | Wolves | Anfield |
| +1 | Darwin Nunez | 18 Jan 2025 | 2-0 | Brentford | Gtech Community Stadium |
| +1 | Harvey Elliott | 09 Dec 2023 | 2-1 | Crystal Palace | Selhurst Park |
| +1 | Roberto Firmino | 16 Oct 2021 | 5-0 | Watford | Vicarage Road |
| +1 | Trent Alexander-Arnold | 10 Apr 2021 | 2-1 | Aston Villa | Anfield |
| +1 | Xherdan Shaqiri | 05 Dec 2018 | 3-1 | Burnley | Turf Moor |
| +1 | Mohamed Salah | 04 Feb 2018 | 2-2 | Tottenham Hotspur | Anfield |
| +1 | Georginio Wijnaldum | 04 Mar 2017 | 3-1 | Arsenal | Anfield |
| +1 pen | James Milner | 26 Nov 2016 | 2-0 | Sunderland | Anfield |
| +1 | Georginio Wijnaldum | 06 Nov 2016 | 6-1 | Watford | Anfield |
| +1 | Philippe Coutinho | 19 Oct 2014 | 3-2 | Queens Park Rangers | Loftus Road |
| +1 pen | Steven Gerrard | 12 Feb 2014 | 3-2 | Fulham | Craven Cottage |
| +1 | Andy Carroll | 10 Apr 2012 | 3-2 | Blackburn Rovers | Ewood Park |
| +1 | Fernando Torres | 22 Jan 2011 | 3-0 | Wolves | Molineux |
| +1 | Ryan Babel | 26 Sep 2009 | 6-1 | Hull City | Anfield |
| +1 | Andrea Dossena | 14 Mar 2009 | 4-1 | Manchester United | Old Trafford |
| +1 | Fernando Torres | 07 Feb 2009 | 3-2 | Portsmouth | Fratton Park |
| +1 | Stephen Warnock | 15 Mar 2006 | 5-1 | Fulham | Anfield |