- Liverpool won the game 2-1 after extra-time with Jimmy Ross scoring in the 113th minute, but the match counted as a draw leaving Ross' goal as inconsequential. The Liverpool Daily Post reported: "At the close of the game, the Barnsley officials laid a protest with the referee in accordance with Rule 17 which provides that extra-time can be only be ordered if both clubs mutually consent. Prior to extra-time being started, Barnsley protested and evidently the match will have to be counted as a draw and replayed at Liverpool."