| Player |
Period |
| Andrew Hannah |
1892-1895 |
| Jimmy Ross |
1895-1897 |
| John McCartney |
1897-1898 |
| Harry Storer |
1898-1899 |
| Alex Raisbeck |
1899-1909 |
| Arthur Goddard |
1909-1912 |
| Ephraim Longworth |
1912-1913 |
| Harry Lowe |
1913-1915 |
| Ephraim Longworth / Don Mackinlay |
1919-1920 |
| Ephraim Longworth |
1920-1922 |
| Don Mackinlay |
1922-1928 |
| Tom Bromilow |
1928-1929 |
| James Jackson |
1929-1930 |
| Tom Morrison |
1930-1931 |
| Tom Bradshaw |
1931-1934 |
| Ernie Blenkinsop / Tom Cooper |
1934-1935 |
| Ernie Blenkinsop |
1935-1936 |
| Ernie Blenkinsop / Tom Cooper |
1936-1937 |
| Tom Cooper |
1937-1939 |
| Matt Busby |
1939-1940 |
| Willie Fagan |
1945-1947 |
| Jack Balmer |
1947-1950 |
| Phil Taylor |
1950-1953 |
| Bill Jones |
1953-1954 |
| Laurie Hughes |
1954-1955 |
| Billy Liddell |
1955-1958 |
| Johnny Wheeler |
1958-1959 |
| Ronnie Moran |
1959-1960 |
| Dick White |
1960-1961 |
| Ron Yeats |
1961-1970 |
| Tommy Smith |
1970-1973 |
| Emlyn Hughes |
1973-1979 |
| Kenny Dalglish |
1979-1979 |
| Phil Thompson |
1979-1981 |
| Graeme Souness |
1982-1984 |
| Phil Neal |
1984-1985 |
| Alan Hansen |
1985-1988 |
| Ronnie Whelan |
1988-1989 |
| Alan Hansen |
1989-1990 |
| Ronnie Whelan |
1990-1991 |
| Steve Nicol |
1990-1991 |
| Mark Wright |
1991-1993 |
| Ian Rush |
1993-1996 |
| John Barnes |
1996-1997 |
| Paul Ince |
1997-1999 |
| Jamie Redknapp |
1999-2002 |
| Sami Hyypia |
2001-2003 |
| Steven Gerrard |
2003- |