Player profile

Donald Mackinlay

Donald Mackinlay

Birthdate: 25 July 1891
Birthplace: Newton Mearns, Scotland
Date of death: 16 September 1959
Other clubs: Newton Swifts (1905-08), Rutherglen Woodburn (1908-09), Newton Villa (1909-10), Prescot Cables (1929-31)
Bought from: Newton Villa
Signed for LFC: 27.01.1910
International debut: 04.02.1922 vs. Wales
International caps: 2/0 - 04.03.1922
Liverpool debut: 20.04.1910
Last appearance: 01.09.1928
Debut goal: 02.11.1912
Last goal: 05.03.1927
Contract expiry: May 1929
Win ratio: 43.32% W:188 D:111 L:135
Honours: League Championship 1921/22, 1922/23
Wartime games/goals: 136 / 24
LFC league games/goals: 393 / 34
Total LFC games/goals: 434 / 35

Player profile

Few came tougher than Donald Mackinlay who was Liverpool's captain from 1922-1928. He certainly enjoyed his two decades at the Reds: "If I had 20 years to go again, I would go back to them," he said in 1955. Mackinlay made his debut for Liverpool 19 years of age on 20 April 1910 when Liverpool defeated Nottingham Forest 7-3 with Jack Parkinson grabbing four. He only made two appearances as left-half the following season and featured on the right and left of the half-back line at the close of 1911/12. Mackinlay was slowly making a name for himself but the question was what was his best position. He played in five different positions in the 1912/13 season mostly as an inside-right where he was said to be "as nippy and quick as a jack-in-the-box." He had quite a magnificent shot in his arsenal and he scored six goals in 23 matches that campaign. He was moved back and forth as well in the following season and after only featuring in two out of the last 11 games he was given the enormous responsibility of playing as left-half in place of injured captain Harry Lowe in the 1914 FA Cup final which Liverpool lost 1-0 to Burnley. Mackinlay appeared regularly for Liverpool during World War I and made 136 appearances and scored 24 goals. Once the League resumed in 1919/20 Mackinlay was a firm fixture in the side and formed probably the best full-back pairing ever in the history of Liverpool with him on the left and Ephraim Longworth on the right. After sharing the captaincy with Longworth in the 1919/20 season he was made sole captain in January 1922 at thirty years of age and held on to this honour until he left Liverpool seven years later.

Mackinlay was the proud general of the Liverpool side that won successive League Championship titles in 1922 and 1923 and had the leadership qualities necessary for such a demanding role. Mackinlay's shooting prowess gave him a return of 34 goals for Liverpool, of which only four came from the penalty spot. One goal possibly more memorable than the rest came on 16 January 1926 in the fifteenth minute of a 2-1 league win against West Ham. Mackinlay was a full ten yards inside his own half when he unleashed a shot that hit the back of the Hammers' net. In honour of his 19 years of service for the club Mackinlay received his fourth benefit from Liverpool in the last game of the 1928/29 season against Manchester City at Anfield. He received a cheque for a total of £468. Mackinlay stayed in the Merseyside area to play non-league football for a while with Prescot Cables and later became a publican in the city of Liverpool. He was a keen golfer and enjoyed playing the drums! Not surprisingly Donald Mackinlay is a member of Liverpool FC's Hall of Fame.

Appearances per season

Season League FA LC Europe Other Total
Totals 393 40 0 0 1 434
1909-1910 1 0 0 0 0 1
1910-1911 2 0 0 0 0 2
1911-1912 7 0 0 0 0 7
1912-1913 22 1 0 0 0 23
1913-1914 16 6 0 0 0 22
1914-1915 20 2 0 0 0 22
1919-1920 41 5 0 0 0 46
1920-1921 35 3 0 0 0 38
1921-1922 29 3 0 0 1 33
1922-1923 42 4 0 0 0 46
1923-1924 39 5 0 0 0 44
1924-1925 28 2 0 0 0 30
1925-1926 41 3 0 0 0 44
1926-1927 28 4 0 0 0 32
1927-1928 40 2 0 0 0 42
1928-1929 2 0 0 0 0 2

A more detailed look at the player's appearances

Total Opponent
24 Sheffield United
23 Sunderland
22 Aston Villa
22 Newcastle United
20 Everton
19 Arsenal
19 Tottenham
19 Blackburn Rovers
18 Bolton Wanderers
17 Burnley
17 Huddersfield Town
17 Manchester United
16 Manchester City
16 WBA
15 Middlesbrough
12 Preston North End
12 Birmingham City
11 Cardiff City
11 Oldham Athletic
10 Chelsea
9 Derby
9 Bradford City
9 Notts County
8 Sheffield Wednesday
8 West Ham United
6 Nottingham Forest
6 Bury
6 Leeds United
6 Leicester City
5 Southampton
4 Bradford Park Avenue
2 Gateshead
2 Stoke City
2 Portsmouth
2 Barnsley
2 Bournemouth
1 QPR
1 Stockport County
1 Wolves
1 Fulham
1 Luton Town
1 Darlington
1 Gillingham
1 Southport
Total Competition
393 League
40 FA Cup
1 Charity Shield

Goals per season

Season League FA LC Europe Other Total
Totals 34 1 0 0 0 35
1909-1910 0 0 0 0 0 0
1910-1911 0 0 0 0 0 0
1911-1912 0 0 0 0 0 0
1912-1913 6 0 0 0 0 6
1913-1914 1 0 0 0 0 1
1914-1915 1 0 0 0 0 1
1919-1920 4 0 0 0 0 4
1920-1921 2 0 0 0 0 2
1921-1922 1 0 0 0 0 1
1922-1923 5 1 0 0 0 6
1923-1924 6 0 0 0 0 6
1924-1925 4 0 0 0 0 4
1925-1926 2 0 0 0 0 2
1926-1927 2 0 0 0 0 2
1927-1928 0 0 0 0 0 0
1928-1929 0 0 0 0 0 0

A more detailed look at the player's goalscoring

Total Competition
34 League
1 FA Cup
Total Open play/Penalty
31 Open play
4 Penalty

Wartime Appearances / Goals

Season Appearances Goals
1915-1916 29 4
1916-1917 35 6
1917-1918 35 5
1918-1919 37 9

Milestone Appearances

# Date Against Stadium Competition
1 20.04.1910 Nottingham Forest Anfield League
50 28.02.1914 Oldham Athletic Boundary Park League
100 01.01.1920 Manchester United Anfield League
150 05.03.1921 Huddersfield Town Leeds Road League
200 16.09.1922 Preston North End Anfield League
250 13.10.1923 Everton Anfield League
300 06.12.1924 WBA Anfield League
350 27.03.1926 WBA The Hawthorns League
400 15.10.1927 Everton Goodison Park League

Milestone Goals

# Minute Date Against Stadium Competition
1 3 02.11.1912 Tottenham Anfield League

Related Articles

Kenneth Campbell’s unique life story - Chapter 1

Scottish keeper, Kenny Campbell, told his life story in the Weekly News. Chapter one was published on 7 May 1921.More

Kenneth Campbell continues his life story – Chapter 2

Scottish keeper, Kenny Campbell, told his life story in the Weekly News. Chapter two was published on 14 May 1921.More

Corner Kick trick

Published 17 January 2009 by David Prentice, Liverpool Echo.More

Donald Mackinlay - The captain speaks out

Few came tougher than Scottish full-back Donald MacKinlay who was a player at Anfield from 1909-1929 and Liverpool's captain from 1921-1928.More

Elisha Scott - Ever so solid guardian

Elisha Scott is without a doubt one of the greatest goalkeepers in Liverpool's history. His career spanned an astonishing 22 years from his arrival in September 1912 until he left in June 1934. More

Related Quotes

"I thought a lot of him. If Jack had had a little more 'devilment' in him, he would have been one of the best inside forwards in the game."

Former Liverpool captain, Don MacKinlay, on Jack Balmer in 1955

"One of the finest centre-halves I have ever seen. I would have loved to have played behind him. What a tragedy it was he was moved about such a lot. Why Liverpool let him go this season I just don’t know."

Former Liverpool captain, Don MacKinlay, on Bill Jones in 1955

He hits the ball with ferocious force, and commands the ball as though it were tied to his boot.

The Liverpool Echo on Donald Mackinlay on 23 September 1918

"I think the game was tougher in my day. I remember one match in the early twenties when Wadsworth injured a leg and I saw blood coming out of his boot. I told him to get some attention to it and his reply was: “Who’s blood is it, yours or mine?’ and went on playing."

63-year-old Donald Mackinlay, former captain of Liverpool, remembers Walter Wadsworth in an interview in 1955.

"He appeared in half a dozen different positions but the thing I remember most was his skill with a free kick. If I was leaving with a message and Liverpool had been awarded a free kick, I would wait until it had been taken because I knew anything could happen. He hit the ball with terrific power but also had a remarkable touch."

Leslie Edwards, the sports editor of the Liverpool Daily Post and Echo couldn’t praise Mackinlay’s abilities highly enough.

"Generally today captains do not have sufficient responsibility. It seems to me that all they do is to take the team out and toss the coin. There’s not enough directing and you hardly hear them shout instructions. In my day I had full control on the field and if there was any decision on changing of positions, I took it. I am speaking generally and not individually, but captains today are not what they used to be. I told my players: “If I have to say anything to you, answer me back and don’t start sulking.”’

Mackinlay, captain of Liverpool 1922-1928, explains the skipper's role in the Evening Express in 1955.

“Red is my colour. I’ll play for Liverpool as long as they will have me. I don’t want to play for anybody else and when I pull off the red shirt for the last time I expect I will finish with football, at any rate as a player.”

Donald Mackinlay was a Red through and through evident in his interview with the Evening Express on the 25th of January 1923

Back