Recreation Ground | Saturday 9 September 1916
| Port Vale | 0 | - | 0 | Liverpool |
| 1 | Ted Taylor |
| 2 | Ephraim Longworth |
| 3 | Tommy Lucas |
| 4 | John Bamber |
| 5 | Arthur Goddard |
| 6 | Donald McKinlay |
| 7 | Ernie Pinkney |
| 8 | Arthur Metcalf |
| 9 | Fred Pagnam |
| 10 | Jimmy Ashcroft |
| 11 | Tommy Cunliffe |