Anfield | Monday 26 April 1943
| Liverpool | 4 | - | 1 | Everton |
| Aggregate score: 6 - 4 | ||||
| 1 | Alf Hobson * |
| 2 | Alfred Leslie Pope* |
| 3 | Jack Westby* |
| 4 | Harry Kaye |
| 5 | Norman Low * |
| 6 | Jack Pilling |
| 7 | Berry Nieuwenhuys |
| 8 | Jack Balmer |
| 9 | Cyril Done |
| 10 | Willie Fagan |
| 11 | Michael Hulligan |