Willie Donnelly arrived at Liverpool from Clyde in May 1896 with a remarkable reputation as a penalty stopper. He was said to have saved 19 of the 21 spot-kicks he faced for the Glasgow club, a record that would have given any penalty taker reason to feel nervous. Donnelly grew up in Glasgow and played for Vale of Clyde and Hibernian before joining Clyde in 1895. He was not a tall goalkeeper: a newspaper report in 1900 described him as shorter than Celtic’s Dan McArthur, who stood 5ft 5in (165 cm). At Anfield, Donnelly faced the challenge of displacing Harry Storer, who had established himself as Liverpool’s first-choice goalkeeper. Storer played in the opening 19 first division matches of 1896/97, up to and including the 3–3 draw with Aston Villa on Christmas Day, before injury gave Donnelly his opportunity. His debut came the following day at Burnley, where Liverpool suffered a 4–1 defeat. Results improved quickly, however. Liverpool won 4–1 at Bolton on New Year’s Day, before Donnelly kept clean sheets in a goalless draw with Sheffield United and a 1–0 victory over Stoke at Anfield. Between those two home games, the Reds also won 2–1 at Wolves. When Storer recovered, Liverpool loaned him to Hibernian, whose regular goalkeeper McColl was injured. The Edinburgh club needed a goalkeeper for a Scottish Cup tie against Rangers, and Liverpool helped them out by allowing Storer to travel north. Donnelly continued in the Liverpool side while his fellow goalkeeper was away.
Donnelly played in two victories during Liverpool’s run to their first FA Cup semi-final. The Reds beat Burton Swifts 4–3 at Anfield in the first round and, after a heavy 6–1 league defeat at Stoke, travelled to West Bromwich Albion for the second round. Goals from Malcolm McVean and Robert Neill gave Liverpool a 2–1 win at Stoney Lane on 13 February 1897. It was Donnelly’s eighth and final first-team appearance for the club. In those eight matches, Donnelly conceded 16 goals and kept two clean sheets. Liverpool won five, drew one and lost two. Storer returned to the side for the FA Cup third-round tie against Nottingham Forest, and Donnelly did not add to his six league and two cup appearances. Donnelly remained at Liverpool until 1898, when he returned to Clyde. Two years later he joined Celtic, where he again found himself competing with an established goalkeeper, Dan McArthur. Donnelly made five league and Scottish Cup appearances for Celtic before moving to Belfast Celtic in 1901.