Done joined Liverpool from Runcorn as an amateur on 18 February 1926 and signed professional forms on 13 April. A full-back, he initially found opportunities in the first team difficult to come by, with Tommy Lucas and Donald McKinlay ahead of him in the pecking order. Done made his senior debut at Bolton Wanderers on New Year's Day 1927, but featured only twice during his first season. He made four further appearances in 1927/28, deputising for Lucas and McKinlay as he gradually gained experience. His breakthrough arrived in 1928/29, when he established himself at left-back, taking over from McKinlay as the latter's distinguished Liverpool career approached its conclusion. Done missed only five league matches that season, making 37 first division appearances and three in the FA Cup. He also opened his Liverpool goalscoring account, finding the net five times in the league. Done also demonstrated an ability to contribute at the other end of the pitch. He scored three penalties during the 1928/29 campaign, including the decisive spot-kick in Liverpool's 2-1 victory over Cardiff City at Ninian Park on 1 April 1929.
Done began the following season as first choice but lost his place to Tommy Lucas after approximately a dozen appearances. Competition for the full-back positions continued to restrict his opportunities, and he was in and out of the side over the next couple of seasons. Nevertheless, he remained an important member of the squad and gradually re-established himself in the first team. A contemporary assessment published by the Derby Daily Telegraph on 28 October 1929 provides an interesting insight into his playing style. Done was praised for his sound judgement when tackling and his ability to kick the ball a considerable distance. The newspaper also highlighted his reputation for striking a stationary ball particularly powerfully, making him a dangerous option when taking free-kicks.
Done became a regular first-team player again during the early 1930s, making 14 appearances in 1930/31, followed by 26 in 1931/32 and 30 in 1932/33. His goalscoring continued too, with two goals in 1930/31 and three the following season. One of his notable contributions came in the 4-3 victory over Manchester City on 21 November 1931, when he scored from the penalty spot. Done continued to feature regularly during 1933/34, making 21 league appearances and four in the FA Cup, while adding two more goals to his Liverpool tally. However, he lost his place in February 1934 and spent most of the remaining 15 months of his Anfield career playing for the reserves. His final first-team appearance came against Leicester City on 17 November 1934. Liverpool enjoyed a convincing 5-1 victory, but Done did not feature again in the senior side. He left the club in May 1935 after nine years at Anfield, subsequently joining Reading.