| # | Players |
| 1 | Bruce Grobbelaar, David James, Sander Westerveld, Jerzy Dudek, Diego Cavalieri, Brad Jones |
| 2 | Rob Jones, Stephane Henchoz, Jan Kromkamp, Álvaro Arbeloa, Andrea Dossena, Glen Johnson |
| 3 | David Burrows, Julian Dicks, Bjørn Tore Kvarme, John Scales, Christian Ziege, Abel Xavier, Steve Finnan, Paul Konchesky, Jose Enrique |
| 4 | Steve Nicol, Jason McAteer, Rigobert Song, Sami Hyypia, Alberto Aquilani, Raul Meireles |
| 5 | Mark Wright, Steve Staunton, Milan Baros, Daniel Agger |
| 6 | Don Hutchison, Phil Babb, Markus Babbel, John Arne Riise, Fábio Aurélio |
| 7 | Nigel Clough, Steve McManaman, Vladimir Smicer, Harry Kewell, Robbie Keane, Luis Suarez |
| 8 | Paul Stewart, Stan Collymore, Øyvind Leonhardsen, Emile Heskey, Steven Gerrard |
| 9 | Ian Rush, Robbie Fowler, Nicolas Anelka, El Hadji Diouf, Djibril Cissé, Fernando Torres, Andy Carroll |
| 10 | John Barnes, Michael Owen, Luis Garcia, Andriy Voronin, Joe Cole |
| 11 | Mark Walters, Jamie Redknapp, Vladimir Smicer, Robbie Fowler, Mark Gonzalez, Yossi Benayoun, Albert Riera, Maxi Rodriguez |
| 12 | Ronnie Whelan, John Scales, Steve Harkness, Sami Hyypia, Jerzy Dudek, Paul Jones, Mauricio Pellegrino, Fábio Aurélio, Dani Pacheco |
| 13 | David James, Michael Stensgaard, Tony Warner, KarlHeinz Riedle, Danny Murphy, Anthony Le Tallec |
| 14 | Jan Mølby, Neil Ruddock, Vegard Heggem, Xabi Alonso, Milan Jovanovic, Jordan Henderson |
| 15 | Jamie Redknapp, Patrik Berger, Salif Diao, Peter Crouch, Yossi Benayoun |
| 16 | Michael Thomas, Sean Dundee, Dietmar Hamann, Jermaine Pennant, Sotirios Kyrgiakos, Sebastian Coates |
| 17 | Steve McManaman, Paul Ince, Steven Gerrard, Josemi Rey, Craig Bellamy, Álvaro Arbeloa, Maxi Rodriguez |
| 18 | Phil Charnock, Ronny Rosenthal, Michael Owen, Jean Michel Ferri, Erik Meijer, John Arne Riise, Antonio Nunez, Dirk Kuyt |
| 19 | Torben Piechnik, Mark Kennedy, Brad Friedel, Pegguy Arphexad, Fernando Morientes, Ryan Babel, Stewart Downing |
| 20 | Stig Inge Bjørnebye, Nick Barmby, Anthony Le Tallec, Scott Carson, Javier Mascherano, Jay Spearing |
| 21 | Mike Marsh, Dominic Matteo, Gary McAllister, Salif Diao, Djimi Traore, Lucas Leiva |
| 22 | Steve Harkness, Jamie Cassidy, Michael Stensgaard, Tony Warner, Titi Camara, Chris Kirkland, Mohamed Sissoko, Emiliano Insúa, Danny Wilson |
| 23 | Robbie Fowler, Jamie Carragher |
| 24 | Mike Hooper, Lee Jones, Danny Murphy, Bernard Diomede, Florent S.-Pongolle, David N'Gog |
| 25 | Neil Ruddock, David Thompson, Igor Biscan, Jose Reina |
| 26 | Tony Warner, Jørgen Nielsen, Richie Partridge, Paul Anderson, Scott Carson, Jay Spearing, Charlie Adam |
| 27 | Mark Gayle, Mark Prudhoe, Stephen Pears, Haukur I. Gudnason, Gregory Vignal, Philipp Degen |
| 28 | Alec Chamberlain, Nicky Rizzo, Steven Gerrard, Richie Partridge, Bruno Cheyrou, Stephen Warnock, Damien Plessis, Christian Poulsen |
| 29 | Brad Friedel, Stephen Wright, Patrice Luzi, Gabriel Paletta |
| 30 | Haukur I. Gudnason, Djimi Traore, Boudewijn Zenden, Daniele Padelli, Charles Itandje |
| 31 | Gareth Roberts, Frode Kippe, David Raven, Nabil El Zhar, Raheem Sterling |
| 32 | Danny Williams, Jon Newby, John Welsh, Boudewijn Zenden, Stephen Darby, Alexander Doni |
| 33 | Leyton Maxwell, Alan Navarro, Neil Mellor, Sebastian Leto, Jonjo Shelvey |
| 34 | Darren Potter, Miki Roque, Martin Kelly |
| 35 | Carl Medjani, Danny Guthrie, Ray Putterill, Conor Coady |
| 36 | Jon Otsemobor, Antonio Barragan, Nathan Eccleston |
| 37 | Jari Litmanen, Zak Whitbread, Lee Peltier, Martin Skrtel |
| 38 | Andrea Dossena, Lauri Dalla Valle, Jon Flanagan |
| 39 | Patrice Luzi, Stephen Darby, Nathan Eccleston, Craig Bellamy |
| 40 | Paul Harrison, David Martin, Daniel Ayala |
| 41 | Mark Smyth, Martin Hansen |
| 42 | Robbie Foy, Nabil El Zhar, Peter Gulacsi |
| 45 | James Smith, Mikel Domínguez, Thomas Ince |
| 46 | Jack Hobbs, David Amoo |
| 47 | Damien Plessis, Dani Pacheco, Andre Wisdom |
| 48 | Emiliano Insúa |
| 49 | Jack Robinson |
This list only includes those players who have been in the startinglineup or on the bench. Players who have been allocated shirts but never played or made the bench aren't included.
* Note, Since the 1992-93 season players have a fixed number.